Quotes of the Week: Press split on Thatcher's legacy to what Cameron calls the Telegraph
The Guardian in a leader on Margaret Thatcher: "Her legacy is of public division, private selfishness and a cult of
greed, which together shackle far more of the human spirit than they
ever set free."
The Daily Telegraph in a leader: "Despite the widespread tributes on her passing
yesterday, Lady Thatcher, of all people, would not have expected her enemies
to wipe the slate clean in death. To paraphrase the words of St Francis of
Assisi which she quoted on entering Downing Street, she certainly brought
truth where there was error, but to deliver harmony was never her fate."
The Daily Mail in a leader: "She was a giant, beside whom other peacetime politicians of the 20th and 21st centuries look like mere pygmies."
Simon Kelner in the Independent: "Above anything else, Mrs Thatcher implanted the gene of greed in the
British soul. And, in the end, that is the poison of her legacy."
The Sun in a leader: "Sun readers benefited as the Grantham grocer’s daughter slashed taxes and let council tenants buy their houses, a measure that spread prosperity among working families more than any since. Of course Mrs T made enemies. The left-wing BBC sneered. Rebuilding the clapped-out and strike-torn 1970s economy could not be pain-free. Bitter memories linger. But Britain emerged far stronger."
The Daily Mirror in a leader: "People's minds were made up long ago on Margaret Thatcher. To some she fought for Britain. Many others, including the Daily Mirror, felt she spent 11 years fighting against Britain."
Rupert Murdoch in The Times: "Margaret Thatcher was a risk-taker. When it came to facing down powerful politicians within her own party or strikers on a picket line, she chose the line of most resistance. She believed in doing the right thing, not taking the easy way out. I found her attitude an inspiration in my business life — and never more so than when faced with the recalcitrance of the print unions in the 1980s."
Mail On Sunday: "Britain's police chiefs are drawing up draconian rules under which the identities of people they arrest will be kept secret from the public. The move, which follows a recommendation by Lord Justice Leveson in his report into press standards, has been branded an attack on open justice and has led to comparisons with police states such as North Korea and Zimbabwe."
The Daily Mail in a leader: "Sweeping people off the street and secretly throwing them in a cell is the terrifying hallmark of totalitarian regimes – not mature democracies like Britain. However, the brutal truth is that, post-Leveson, such secrecy is becoming the norm in the state sector. Consider the Home Office edict – certain to deter officers from speaking to the Press – which says that senior police should record all their contacts with journalists in an official log. Or the plan to change the law to make it easier for police to seize confidential material given to reporters and force them to reveal the identity of whistleblowers."
Nick Cohen in The Observer:"The worst of it to my journalist's mind is that the British have not
been able to tell their own stories without fear of retribution. Hugh Tomlinson QC,
the chairman of Hacked Off, a malign organisation that dumb liberals
think is on their side, fought for months to stop the public knowing
that Fred Goodwin was having an affair at the very moment when his bank
was hurtling toward ruin. The parliamentary commission on banking standards'
report on the collapse of HBOS, just published, has many virtues. Its
greatest is that parliamentary privilege – a right to free speech
Parliament will not extend to the rest of us – allows the commission to
speak without authoritarian lawyers and judges blacking out the detail."
Guardian readers' editor Chris Elliott in his Open door column: "Criticism of the Guardian's coverage of parts of the UK that are not England – even parts of
England that are not London – is a constant theme in complaints to the
office of the readers' editor, often fairly. As the evolution of
devolution has continued, London-based reporters and editors have not
always been quick to grasp the different roles and responsibilities of
the constituent parts of the UK in the not so new order."
Boris Johnson in theNew Statesman on how when he was editor of The Spectator he tried and failed to get Polly Toynbee to write for him: "At the end of a harrowing conversation, she said: 'You don’t understand.
You think this is all some game, some debating forum for civilised
adults. But this is serious. You are on one side and I am on the other.' Shortly afterwards, she vented a volcanic piece, accusing everyone at
the Spectator of being effete, slimy, bullying creeps. The
article was illustrated by a picture of Auberon Waugh as a human turd
about to be flushed down the pan – and the poor chap had only just died."
Dan Hodges on his Telegraph blog: "I think the House of Commons assembled on
Wednesday to honour a woman of conviction. And like it or not, a woman
of conviction was what it got to see. Am I Glenda Jackson’s son? Yes, I
Telegraph editor Tony Gallagher in City University'sXCity magazine: "We have been persistent critics of the Government. Not for nothing has David Cameron been heard referring to the 'fucking Telegraph'."
I am a freelance journalist based in the UK and was deputy editor of Press Gazette, the journalists' magazine, from 1993 until 2006. I want to give an independent view on media matters.
You can contact me with stories, ideas and comments by email at firstname.lastname@example.org You can also follow me on Twitter @jonslattery